Reporter’s Notebook: My Political Depression, My Personal Hope

dsc08398The Huffington Post, May 21, 2010

I’m not sure I should be saying this publicly, but I’ve not been writing much lately because I’ve been in a bit of a depression.

A political depression, that is. Interviews, research, press releases, and headlines pile on top of me, one after another, leaving me heavy and defeated. Two Palestinian-Israeli activists were arrested and, initially, news of their detainment was gagged. As proximity talks began Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu proclaimed, on Jerusalem Day, that building will continue in Jerusalem and that the capital will remain “united.” And, in annexed East Jerusalem, Palestinians receive appallingly few services from the “unified” municipality.

Sometimes, I feel so thick with it all I can’t find the strength to write about it.

Continue reading “Reporter’s Notebook: My Political Depression, My Personal Hope”

We don’t have another country

dsc09595Palestine Note, May 27, 2010

More than 6000 demonstrators gathered in the Tel Aviv Museum courtyard Tuesday night to protest the planned deportation of approximately 1200 children of illegal migrant laborers.

The event came in the wake of the news that the governmental committee, convened to determine the children’s fate, had decided to recommend permanent residency. It is unsure exactly what constraints would be placed on eligibility.

Another question mark is whether or not Interior Minister Eli Yishai will agree with the ruling. Despite harsh criticism from both the public and members of the Knesset, Yishai has stood by his decision to deport the children and their families.

Yishai is expected to rule on the committee’s recommendations next week.

With the expulsion planned for the end of the school year, Tuesday’s protest—organized by the grassroots movement Israeli Children, UNICEF Israel, and Israel’s National Student Union—was an emotional appeal to the government to cancel the imminent deportation.

Under the banner of “We don’t have another country,” the children and their raised signs that read “Don’t deport us,” and “Children of Israel.”

Dozens of the 1200 kids slated for deportation took to the stage and, in fluent Hebrew, sang “I don’t have another country”, a patriotic Israeli song known by most schoolchildren.

Journalists Guy Meroz and Orly Vilnai acted as hosts. Speakers included Israeli Children founder Rotem Ilan, Chairman of UNICEF Israel Moriel Matalon, Knesset Members Nitzan Horowitz (Meretz), Dov Khenin (Hadash), and Minister of Minorities Avishay Braverman (Labor), amongst others. Several musical acts performed, as well.

Addressing the crowd, which some estimated to be as high as 8000, Ilan said, “Those supporting the deportation, led by Interior Minister Eli Yishai…”

The demonstrators booed, as they did throughout the evening any time Yishai’s name was uttered. Ilan nodded and remarked, “He deserves it.”

“[Yishai and his supporters] are speaking all the time of what frightens them about foreign workers. But I want to explain to them today what frightens me…

“It frightens me to live in a society that brings a human [to Israel] but treats them like machines. It frightens me that our country hasn’t learned how to treat a foreigner. It frightens me that xenophobia is developing in our society encouraged by a government campaign. It frightens me that the country is considering deporting and arresting innocent children…”

But seeing the crowd before her and considering the strides her small, volunteer-based organization has made, Ilan said, “It gives me hope that it’s still possible to make a change in Israeli society.”

Looking on, Teresa, a Filipino worker who faces deportation along with her husband and their five-year-old son remarked that she was deeply touched by the both the event and the support of the Israeli public. She pressed her hand to her heart as she searched for the words.

Finally, switching from English to Hebrew, Teresa said, “I’m very happy to know that a lot of Israelis love us.”

It has been a difficult period for Teresa and her family since the Oz Unit, the strong arm of the Population, Immigration, and Border Authority, took to the streets in July. Of the possible deportation, Teresa said, “It will be very hard for him. Always I am asking him if he wants to go to the Philippines and he says ‘no.'”

Like many of the 1200 children, Teresa’s son attends an Israeli kindergarten and speaks only English and Hebrew. His favorite holiday, Teresa remarked, is Hanukah.

“Israel won’t deport children. Period. Never,” Meroz declared.

Speaking to Palestine Note, Ilan remarked, “[The children] are absorbed into Israeli society. They speak Hebrew; they celebrate the [Jewish] holidays.” Ilan pointed out that the children are enthusiastic participants in the scouts and youth movements, activities popular with Israeli youth.

“They don’t even speak Taglaog,” Ilan added, referring to the fact that most of the parents of the 1200 children are from the Philippines. Many are single moms who lost their legal status due to an Israeli policy that forbids foreign workers from giving birth in the country, forcing them to choose between their visa and their baby.

In regards to this policy, Ilan remarked, “These regulations are cruel and shouldn’t be in any moral country.”

Photo: Mya Guarnieri. Green sign reads “Israel is my home. Here I learned to read Hebrew. All my friends are here. I am an Israeli child.

Making the best of a bad situation

dsc02276The Jerusalem Post, May 28, 2010

Like many of Israel’s migrant laborers, Usha, 26, lives with exploitation. Hired as a caregiver, she is used as a full-time servant instead. “I take care of seven people and a baby,” she says. “I clean the house. I take the kids to school.”

Her employer’s demands are unreasonable, impossible. Once he forced her to clean the same bathroom three times in one day. “Three times,” Usha repeats with a sigh. Occasionally, he takes her to his business in Ramat Gan and has her work there, too.

Usha, from India, worries that she’ll lose her visa or end up with an employer who doesn’t pay at all. So she stays. She has complained to her employer about her work load and has asked him to up her salary. He refused.

“Rich people [are] very stingy,” Usha says, wagging her finger in the air as though she were scolding her employer. She laughs and her cousin, Gita, 24, joins in.

It’s a Saturday night in Levinsky Park. The two relax in the grass, Usha wearing Western clothes; Gita wrapped in a lime-green sari. Despite their different dress, the cousins are working towards a common goal—independence. Both hope to avoid arranged marriage, they explain. They want to do things on their own terms.

Continue reading “Making the best of a bad situation”

Amnesty International: “Much of Gaza was razed to the ground…”

The Huffington Post, May 29, 2010

Destroyed houses, tent camps, clouds of white phosphorous–these were just a few of the images of Gaza included in the video that accompanied Amnesty International’s annual human rights report, which was released yesterday.

The report covers 2009, including Operation Cast Lead, which began in late December 2008 and ended in January 2009. “Israeli forces committed war crimes and other serious breaches of international law in the Gaza Strip during [the] 22-day military offensive,” Amnesty states.

“Among other things, they carried out indiscriminate and disproportionate attacks against civilians, targeted and killed medical staff, used Palestinians as ‘human shields’, and indiscriminately fired white phosphorous over densely populated residential areas… Much of Gaza was razed to the ground, leaving vital infrastructure destroyed, the economy in ruins and thousands of Palestinians homeless.”

Continue reading “Amnesty International: “Much of Gaza was razed to the ground…””

Israeli activists call for ships to enter Gaza

dsc09618Maan News Agency, May 31, 2010
(click here for Arabic)

Two of a growing number of Israeli protesters at the port of Ashdod jumped into the sea Monday afternoon, calling for an end to Israel’s siege on Gaza and condemning the attack on the Freedom Flotilla.

Reporting from Ashdod, Mya Guarnieri said police had stopped a busload of protesters and told them to return to Tel Aviv. After half an hour being held up on the bus, the protesters joined a group that numbered 200 by 1:30.

Israeli’s gathered to voice dissent against the shooting death of at least ten Palestinian solidarity activists from some 40 nations on the Freedom Flotilla, as simultaneous protests erupt in other areas.

By 3pm, pro-army activists arrived at the port, waving Israeli flags and banners congratulating the Israeli army on the deaths, saying “All the honor to the army,” singing national songs and waving a banner with a photo of the ship saying “terror out,” as the protest appeared to lull. Border police followed the pro-army activists onto the scene, from where witnesses said they could see little of the action.

Media were also being kept away from the port, with cameras set up on a hill almost a kilometer away from the shore.

A second mass rally was called for 7pm in Tel Aviv, outside Israel’s Ministry of Defense, with activist Uri Averny calling together the Israeli left, saying “this night a crime was perpetrated in the middle of the sea, by order of the government of Israel and the IDF Command… A warlike attack against aid ships and deadly shooting at peace and humanitarian aid activists. It is a crazy thing that only a government that crossed all red lines can do.”

Israeli forces announced a state of high alert throughout the country and occupied Palestinian territories following their navy’s attack on the Flotilla, with Gaza crossings sealed and checkpoints expected to be operating at minimum capacity as reports say officials are considering sealing access to the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem in light of Palestinian anger over the attack on the ships.

Guarnieri said that as protesters continued to arrive on the scene, police, border guards and naval officers appeared on the scene to corral demonstrators into a small area.

Speaking with Guarnieri upon arrival in Ashdod, Coalition of Women for Peace member Dalit Baum called the sea-raid of the boats proof that “Israel does not care about international public opinion, it’s time for the world to do something, for Israel to know that it can’t continue to enjoy economic and diplomatic support from the western world.”

Baum continued, saying “I think it’s very important for Israelis to be on these boats, I wish I could be there, I think this is a tremendous civic duty and I think if there is a chance that we can get closer to the people we should get as close as we can.”

About 50 protesters and media crews were gathered on the edge of the port, which is designated a closed military zone, preventing the group from meeting the boats, visible on the horizon.

Police observe Tel Aviv protesters

Guarnieri said one police van observing the gathering was joined by two others as activists arrived in a Tel Aviv’s Levinski garden, preparing to travel to the Port of Ashdod, and began questioning a bus driver preparing to transport the group.

“They were asking him his name and ID number, and questioning him as to who ordered the bus,” Guarnieri said, noting the driver was a Palestinian citizen of Israel.

Israeli activist Uri Averny said early on Monday that a protest would be held against the “bloody attack on the Gaza aid flotilla.” The demonstration was set to take place where the detained flotilla activists are held in Ashdod.

*Photo: Mya Guarnieri

Departed

715559291

Tablet, May 7, 2010

Standing outside of his Galilee home, Fadi, once a high-ranking officer of the South Lebanese Army (SLA), remarks on how close he still lives to Lebanon. He gestures to the low-slung mountains as though he is trying to sweep them from the horizon. “If that hill wasn’t there, we could see Tsfat,” he says, “and after that, Lebanon.” The small village he was born and raised in isn’t far off.

Like South Lebanon, his childhood memories were overrun with Syrian troops and Palestinian fighters. Fadi, who asked to be identified by a pseudonym, was a young boy when civil war began. He joined the SLA as a teenager.

While the SLA was predominantly Christian, both Shiite and Druze were represented in its ranks, which numbered over 3000. Established from a fragment of the Lebanese Army, the militia was first headed by Saad Haddad; after Haddad’s death in 1984, Antoine Lahad took the helm. But Israel, ultimately, controlled both men.

Continue reading “Departed”

The view from there

joelschalit_2The Jerusalem Post, May 7, 2010

Not long after US Vice President Joe Biden touched down in Israel, Interior Minister Eli Yishai announced plans to build 1600 new homes in an East Jerusalem settlement. The move, publicly condemned by Biden, seemed like a slap in the face of the American administration. Biden criticized the “substance and timing of the announcement” adding “We must build an atmosphere to support negotiations, not complicate them.”

But Yishai’s move, and the crisis that followed, was unsurprising to some, like Israeli-American author Joel Schalit.”Biden’s visit offered Yishai the opportunity to act out Israel’s desire to be ‘free’ of its dependency on the Americans.”

“Even though the Americans remain military allies, they have never been more diplomatically and, even more significantly, ideologically alienated from Israel,” Schalit explains. “Yet our government continues to chip away at American goodwill…”

Continue reading “The view from there”

The Road to Nowhere

FILES-BRITAIN-MIDEAST-PALESTINIAN-GOVERNMENT-FAYYAD
Maan News Agency, May 5, 2010
The Huffington Post, May 4, 2010
Zeek, May 4, 2010

Mahmoud, a Palestinian taxi driver, isn’t taking proximity talks seriously. “They just talk and talk and talk,” he says, as we wait at a red light in Jerusalem. “Nothing changes.”

His cynicism is shared by both the Palestinian Authority and Netanyahu’s administration. Israel is concerned with what Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon calls an “unprecedented wave of incitement”—the PA-led boycott of settlement-produced goods and the naming of public locales for Palestinian militants. The PA points to the fact that Israel won’t stop building settlements.

Stakes are always high when it comes to peace talks. But, in light of Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad’s plans to unilaterally declare a Palestinian state, this time they’re even higher.

“In terms of sheer casualties, a state before peace could be a very risky move,” says Dr. Uriel Abulof, an assistant professor in Tel Aviv University’s Department of Political Science.

Continue reading “The Road to Nowhere”

Refugees: “Let us work to survive”

dsc09409Al Jazeera English, May 1, 2010

Traffic came to a stop in the center of Tel Aviv on Friday as hundreds took to the streets for May Day.

African refugees were amongst them. They carried hand-painted signs reading “Refugees’ rights now” and “Let us work to survive” in bold, red letters.

Their words point to a political environment that is increasingly hostile to asylum seekers.

Israel is home to some 20,000 African refugees. About half come from Eritrea, a country gripped by a brutal dictatorship. More than a third escaped civil war and genocide in Sudan. But Israel has granted asylum status to less than 200 since its 1948 establishment, which came in the wake of the Holocaust.

Continue reading “Refugees: “Let us work to survive””

Urban sanctuaries

dsc09026The Jerusalem Post, April 30, 2010
The National, May 17, 2010

Nearly half of Ruby Austria’s 150 congregants have disappeared since the Oz Unit, a strong arm of the immigration police, took to the streets in July. Thousands of foreign workers have left the country out of fear. Hundreds have been deported.

In recent months, many churches that minister to migrant laborers have seen their numbers grow so thin that they’ve been forced to close. But Austria is busier than ever. She receives a constant stream of congregants worried about Israel’s plan to expel some 1200 minors, along with their parents, at the end of the school year.

Austria, who also runs a kindergarten for children of foreign workers, often finds herself consoling mothers and fathers when they pick up their kids. “They come to me and cry—what will happen, what will be? The mothers have fear all the time, the [sense of] being threatened,” she says. “The moms are harassed and interrogated. [The Oz Unit] takes them in the [police] van and drives them around.”

“Even if you don’t tell the children, they feel what the mother feels,” Austria continues. “When the Oz Unit first came, the children were crying all the time, some weren’t eating, some stopped speaking. They were very fearful. It was very hard…”

Austria says that it’s important to her to “be strong” for the families who need support right now. But it’s hard. Austria, 36, is also an illegal resident. She, along with her husband and their seven-year-old daughter, faces deportation to the Philippines.

Austria, who holds a college degree in nursing, arrived in Israel 13 years ago to work as a caregiver. Her employer died and her visa ended in 2002, just before a major wave of arrests and expulsions began. Israel targeted men, in hopes of encouraging families to return to their countries of origin. Husbands and male pastors were deported; giving rise to single moms and women at the pulpit.

The difficulties facing the community were inspiration for Austria to become a pastor. Despite her illegal status, she began attending the Bible Institute of Jerusalem and, after completing her studies, was ordained as a minister.

Austria isn’t your typical Christian pastor, however. Her approach to religion is deeply informed by Judaism. Austria’s pulpit is adorned with a hannukiah. She dons silver earrings of a menorah and a fish, a symbol of Christianity, joined together by a Star of David. She touches the jewelry and says, “This means that the Jew and the Christian are one.”

Austria incorporates Hebrew into her services, makes Kiddush, and lights Shabbat candles. And some members of her congregation wear talit during prayers. It helps them “feel the presence of God,” Austria explains.

As is true of many Christians, particularly Filipinos, Austria feels a strong connection to Israel. “We have one God, because we [Christians] also believe in the [Old Testament]. We thank you—thank Israel—for giving us the Bible. If not, we would still be worshipping the stars, the woods, the sun,” she says.

But when she considers the way the government treats migrant laborers, she is fraught with “great friction, emotionally.”

Today, Israel is home to approximately 300,000 migrant laborers, primarily from the Philippines, Thailand, China, India, Nepal, and Sri Lanka, with the Filipino community making up the largest group. It is estimated that 250,000 of the workers are illegal. A majority arrived legally but became illegal after overstaying or losing their visas.

Due to the plans to deport Israeli-born children, the current crackdown has drawn tremendous criticism. And, pointing to Prime Minister Netanyahu’s claims that foreign workers threaten the Jewish character of the state, some observers have called the campaign racist.

Sabine Haddad, spokesperson for the Ministry of the Interior, denied that moves against migrant laborers are related to preserving the Jewish character of the state. “There is no problem with legal workers,” she said. The Oz Unit is simply trying to enforce the law. “Our unit is doing what the government says.”

Haddad emphasized that the Oz Unit is not currently arresting or deporting children or their parents. A special committee is convening to consider the deportation of families, Haddad said. If the plan is finalized, it represents a move against illegal residents, not against children, parents, or foreign workers in general.

Speaking to The Jerusalem Post recently, Tamar Shwartz of the NGO Mesila—Aid and Information Center for the Foreign Community—remarked that recent events have “threatened the social network” of migrant laborers and refugees.

While children have been particularly affected by the crackdown, Shwartz said the whole community “is very much weakened by the activities of the immigration police…. Everything that makes this community strong is a blessing.”

In the midst of the crisis, Austria offers weekend services as well as impromptu prayer sessions. When the church is occupied by the kindergarten, Austria ministers upstairs on the roof. “Almost every day, there are men and women stopping by to pray,” she says. “Almost every day, my cell phone is full of text and [voicemail]. What do the messages say? “Please pray for me.”

When someone is in urgent need of spiritual guidance, Austria grabs child-sized chairs from the gan and heads to the roof, an urban sanctuary. Although it’s close to the Central Bus Station, it’s quiet and still up here.
But sometimes, the Oz Unit is in sight below.

Austria’s church is not always a safe haven. About a year ago immigration police showed up, without a warrant. “They thought I was hiding someone here,” she says. “They searched all the rooms and the roof.” The police also threatened to shut down her kindergarten.

In December, the Oz Unit conducted a similar raid on a South Tel Aviv church popular with African asylum seekers—despite the fact that protocol forbids immigration police from entering houses of worship.

Still, the women pastors see the church as a place to hit back.

On a recent weeknight, a large group of foreign workers and African refugees gathered in Christ the Redeemer Assembly, where Filipina Marife Adriano is a pastor. But they weren’t there for a sermon. Congregants were participating in a seminar titled “Know your Rights,” which included speakers from local human rights organizations.

Sitting in the audience, Adriano, 38, remarks, “Church is also a way to help people, to communicate… We can organize something for [migrant laborers and asylum seekers], give counseling to the people.” She estimates that since the Oz Unit has begun its work, however, about half of the ministries frequented by foreign workers have closed.

But Adriano’s work is not only in the church. “It’s also outside. If people have questions, hear rumors, they are calling.” In turn, Adriano contacts NGOs and does her best to get more information for her congregants. She is also active with Israeli Children—a grassroots movement that is fighting the deportation of minors who lack legal status.

Although Adriano and her nine-year-old son received permanent residency in 2006, and are safe from expulsion, she understands the fear plaguing the community now. “When they started deporting the first time [in 2002], I decided to go home,” Adriano, a single mother, recalls. “My pastor said ‘Pray and fast and see what the Holy Spirit will lead you to do.’ I decided not to go home. I felt there is something more I have to do here in Israel.”

Shortly after this epiphany, Adriano began to lead a bible study in her South Tel Aviv apartment. She gradually became more active and in 2007, she was ordained as a minister by a pastor visiting from the Philippines.

“I feel like I have freedom here [in the church],” Adriano says. She hopes that faith will bring the same feeling to those who seek her ministries.

Like Austria, Adriano counsels her congregants spiritually and emotionally around the clock. “Their problem is your problem,” she says. “As a minister, a pastor, you have to sacrifice yourself.”