Al Jazeera English, February 6, 2011
As Egyptians take to the streets to demand their freedom, I ask a Muslim in Yafo if we’ll see the same in Israel. “I don’t think so,” he answers. “Even with all the mess here, we have democracy.”
Do we? And for how much longer?
As we speak, the Knesset is debating one of a slew of anti-democratic bills. Some of the legislation targets Palestinian citizens of Israel—people like this man and his wife, a petite woman who is quick to offer me coffee and her opinions.
If the Admissions Committee law passes, for example, this young couple and their three children could find themselves barred from living in certain communities and villages, even those built on public land.
If the Nakba Bill is approved, organizations that commemorate the 1948 expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians will be ineligible for public funds. This is a “watered down” version of the bill. The original version sought to imprison anyone who publicly marked the Nakba Day.
Other legislation aims to silence individuals and groups that criticize the government.
The Israeli Democracy Institute (IDI) says that such bills, coupled with things like the rabbis’ letter, are “serious threats” to the country. Explaining that the death of democracy is “a gradual process,” the IDI, a non-partisan think-tank based in Jerusalem, warns:
“[P]eople who are concerned but are waiting for the ‘moment of real danger’ to abandon their routines and take steps to defend democracy are making a mistake. The moment of real danger is now.”
It’s worth noting that the IDI managed to publish this op-ed in The Jerusalem Post, a center-right daily. And, in recent weeks, the center-left newspaper Haaretz has published a number of pieces voicing similar concerns about Israel’s democracy. That suggests that even the Israeli center—however uninvolved and however apathetic—is worried about the state of the state.
***
Some critics, myself included, would say that Israel was never a democracy in the true sense of the word. Arab citizens of the state were under martial law from 1949 to 1966. A year later, the decidedly undemocratic occupation of Palestinian territories began.
Knesset Member Dov Khenin, of the Jewish-Arab party Hadash, puts it like this: “In Israel there is a specific democratic space. It’s not big, and in connection to the topic of Arabs, it’s even smaller. But the space is important to us because it’s the space we’re standing in.”
He gestures to the room in Yafo, where he is giving a talk under the banner of “The Danger of Fascism.” There are about 20 people present—a sad number considering what’s at stake here.
“What has happened in recent years—and it’s a process that’s very dangerous—is that the space is being attacked and clamped down upon,” Khenin continues.
“One of the attacks is coming in the form of racism,” he says. He explains that while Arab Knesset Members have always been regarded with suspicion—the vicious verbal assault MK Haneen Zoabi faced in the Knesset after she participated in the flotilla comes to my mind—the government is “now attacking not just the Arab Knesset Members but all the Arab population.”
“The process is spreading,” Khenin adds. “And if we look at the past two years, it’s not just the Arab population, [the government is] also attacking Jews who think differently.”
***
That assault is coming in the form of anti-democratic legislation that would limit free speech and campaigns against Israeli human rights organizations.
The Boycott Bill seeks to criminalize those who advocate for the international boycott of Israel, subjecting them to steep fines.
The Anti-Incitement Bill criminalizes those who publish anything that denies Israel’s Jewish and democratic character. Because I have authored articles calling for a bi-national democracy, this one could land me in jail. (And, if I’m already headed for the clinker, I might as well state the obvious: a country that must force people to call it democratic, on pain of imprisonment, isn’t a democracy).
And the Knesset is considering the creation of committees that will investigate the funding of left-wing civil and human rights organizations—most of which are critical of the Israeli occupation. Critics have likened the move to a political witch hunt as right-wing groups will not be investigated. They also point out that such an investigation, which is the responsibility of the legal branch, would exceed the Knesset’s power.
So the question remains: will Israel become out right fascist?
***
At an October protest against legislation commonly referred to as the loyalty oath—a bill that would require non-Jews seeking Israeli citizenship to pledge allegiance to a “Jewish and democratic” state—Dr. Gavriel Solomon, a prominent academic and peace activist, likened Israel to Nazi Germany, circa 1935. That was the year that the Nuremberg Laws—racist legislation that led to the systematic and deadly persecution of Jews—were created.
“There were no [concentration] camps yet but there were racist laws,” he said. “And we are heading towards these kinds of laws.”
Speaking to Al Jazeera by telephone, Solomon softened his message, remarking that, “The question was really if we are not sliding towards fascism.”
“Even though we very clearly have people like [hawkish Foreign Minister Avigdor] Lieberman who are not sensitive to the issue… there enough people on the right not to allow such Lieberman laws to go through,” he says, pointing to members of Likud like Dan Meridor.
But the Israeli daily Haaretz recently revealed that right-wing activists are working in Jewish settlements to recruit Likud voters who would push Meridor out of the Knesset.
And rightists are taking other moves to silence dissent. Haaretz reports that they have successfully shut down the Facebook pages of several left-wing groups.
Depending on how these right-wingers spin their projects—are they trying to silence dissent? Or are they taking necessary measures for Israel’s image and security?—the Israeli public is willing to march lockstep with them.
A recent poll, conducted by the Geocartography Knowledge Group, found that more than half of Jewish Israelis are willing to limit press freedom if the media poses a threat to the state’s image. And nearly two-thirds would clamp down on freedom of speech for the sake of security.
***
The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) is one of the organizations leading the fight against anti-democratic legislation. Spokeswoman Ronit Sela remarks, “I think what’s troublesome is that it’s not just groups or people on the street that are voicing things that are racist and anti-democratic… [it is] the Knesset and the government.”
“And we don’t see such a strong opposition from the Prime Minister [Benjamin Netanyahu].”
Sela emphasizes that whether or not the bills pass they are damaging.
“When the person on the street reads in the newspaper that there are Knesset members who want to interrogate these organizations about their funding, it makes an impression,” she says. “Damage has already been done to the reputation of the human rights organizations, to the Arabs of this country and to the Jewish citizens who work with them.”
“It is anti-democratic content that is slipping into the Israeli mainstream,” she adds.
Just as Sela warns against focusing solely on the passage of legislation, Khenin cautions against pinning Israel’s political crisis on one person or group.
“When we’re talking about the rise of fascism in Israel, we’re talking about the groups of extreme rabbis and the settler armies,” he says. “But it’s a mistake to focus just on those groups… The danger of fascism is wider.”
He points to a weak High Court, problems within Israel’s political parties, as well as a center that has disappeared and can no longer keep the right in check.
“We need to understand that fascism isn’t an expression of power, it’s an expression of weakness.”
While many Israelis equate fascism with Lieberman, Khenin points out that not long before Netanyahu become Prime Minister he called Palestinian citizens of Israel a demographic threat.
“And now he’s head of the government,” Khenin says.
The fight for democracy must be a struggle against the established right or, as Khenin says, “This government: Netanyahu, Lieberman, [and Defense Minister Ehud] Barak.”
And because the death of democracy is tied up with the occupation—“A people who oppresses another people cannot be free,” Khenin says, paraphrasing Friedrich Engel—Jews and Arabs must fight this war together.
***
Will the people hit the streets for democracy?
Oded is a 29-year-old industrial designer who asked to be identified by a pseudonym because he fears social and professional repercussions from voicing his political opinions and doing so in an “Arab” media outlet.
He says that, if current trends continue, it’s likely that Israel will see a fascist government. In the past, Oded recalls, dissenting opinions were tolerated. “Now, it’s impossible to say anything against the state or the government. If you do, you’re a ‘traitor’ because the state is the value that’s important.’”
And Oded, the grandson of Holocaust survivors, remarks that this kind of ultra-nationalism is at the root of both racism and fascism.
“Are you going to protest?” I ask.
“No,” he says. “Right now, however self-centered it sounds, it doesn’t really interest me because I have things in my personal life that are more important. And I’m lazy.”
When asked if he understands that such apathy is what allows extremists to take over, Oded nods.
“I think [if we had a fascist government,] I would just leave,” he says, voicing something I have heard many Israelis say.
Here’s the good news. A recent demonstration held under the banner “March for Democracy while we still can,” attracted some 20,000. Many held signs that read, “Jews and Arabs refuse to be enemies.”
And, on Saturday night, some 200 Palestinian citizens of Israel and far-left Jewish Israeli activists gathered to stand in solidarity with Egypt’s pro-democracy protestors and to demonstrate against oppression in Israel.
A Palestinian-Israeli demonstrator said, in Hebrew, that the Middle East must get rid of “The three b’s: Barak, Bibi [Netanyahu], and Mu-barak.”
While meaningful change is probably a long way off for Israel—it’s going to take something huge, like fascism, to wake Jewish Israelis from their apathy and dreams of maintaining both a Zionist and democratic state—change is in the air.
*Photo: Mya Guarnieri. A protester holds a sign that reads, “The government is screwing us all. It’s allows [we’re allowed] to say NO!”